ABSTRACT
Background: Sero-studies of SARS-CoV-2 have used antibody (Ab) responses to spike (S) and nucleocapsid (N) antigens to differentiate mRNA vaccinated (S+/N-) from infected (S+/N+) individuals. We performed testing on wellcharacterized subjects to determine how repeated vaccination or infection, and time from those exposures, influence these Ab levels. Method(s): Samples from individuals with known infection status: prepandemic negative controls n=462;first-time infected n=237 (~45 days post);vaccinated after infection n= 34 (~40 days post-vaccination and ~180 days post-infection);fully vaccinated n=158 (~50 days post);boosted n=31 (~30 days post);breakthrough n=18 (~14 days post-infection);reinfected n=10 (varied). Longitudinal samples (n=51) from subjects with evidence of reinfection (symptoms and/or positive rapid antigen test), were tested to determine the impact of the order of infection and/or vaccination on the magnitude of the anti-S and anti-N IgG Ab detected in the blood. Testing was performed with MesoScale Diagnostics (Gaithersburg, MD) assay. Outcomes are presented in WHO International Binding Antibody Units (BAU/mL). The cutoff for a positive result was 18 BAU for S and 12 BAU for N. Result(s): The median amount of Ab (IQR) in BAU for each group (Figure A) was: pre-pandemic negative controls S 0.53(0.27,1.03), N 0.55(0.18,1.67);first-time infected S 114(51,328), N 70(29,229);vaccinated after infection S 4367(2479,4837), N 15(7,35);fully vaccinated S 998(586,1529), N 0.31(0.16,0.68);boosted S 2988(1768,3522), N 0.59(0.32,1.03);breakthrough S 2429(2032,3413), N 2.5(0.93,8.6);reinfected S 1533(486,4643), N 7.8(2.6,62). For the breakthrough and second infections 17% and 40% were seropositive to N, respectively. Longitudinal analysis (Figure B) of those with multiple infections showed that all those with a positive rapid antigen test for their second infection had an increase in N Ab. Conclusion(s): The prevalence of antibodies to nucleocapsid cannot be used to determine the proportion of individuals infected to SARS-CoV-2 in a vaccinated population. Booster, repeated, and breakthrough infections are associated with IgG Ab levels to S >400 BAU/mL. A majority of breakthrough infections did not elicit an Ab response to N. For those with repeated infection, a minority elicited antibody responses to N. This could be related to misdiagnosis or the burden of infection, as only those who were positive by rapid antigen assay (indicative of a high viral load) had an increase in N Ab.
ABSTRACT
Background: The prevalence of vaccinated, previously infected, and individuals at risk of SARS-CoV-2 infection is important for epidemiologic studies and public health interventions. Asymptomatic infections and reluctance to disclose vaccination status hinder accurate assessments of the current state of the epidemic. Since COVID-19 vaccines generate immune responses to spike (S1), but not nucleocapsid (N), it is possible to differentiate between vaccinated, infected, and unexposed individuals by comparing antibody reactivity to each antigen. The MSD V-Plex SARS-CoV-2 IgG assay can potentially differentiate each state in one test by simultaneously evaluating IgG reactivity to the S1, receptor binding domain (RBD), and N proteins. Methods: The MSD assay was validated with three sample sets: known vaccination with no previous infection (n=158);known infected and not vaccinated (n=157);and samples collected prior to the COVID-19 pandemic in 2016 (n=144). Of the previously infected individuals, 15 (9.6%) were hospitalized;sample collection occurred a median of 48 days after a PCR-positive result. Using an algorithm, samples with positive results on both S1 and RBD but negative on N were classified as vaccinated. Samples with a positive result on all three proteins were considered to be infected with the possibility of subsequent vaccination. Any other result was classified as unexposed. Sensitivity and specificity for each state were calculated. Results: Reactivity to each antigen is shown in the figure. 100% (95% confidence interval [CI] 97.7-100), 92% (95% CI 86.3-95.5), and 0.7% (95% CI 0.02-3.8) of vaccinated, infected, and unexposed samples were positive for S1. 100% (95% CI 97.7-100.0%), 91% (95% CI 85.5-95.0%), and 0.7% (95% CI 0.02-3.8%) of vaccinated, infected and unexposed samples were positive for RBD. 0% (95% CI 0-2.3), 86% (95% CI 79.6-91.0), and 2.1% (95% CI 0.4-6.0) of vaccinated, infected and unexposed samples were positive for N. Algorithm sensitivity and specificity for classification of vaccinated samples were 100% (95% CI 97.7-100) and 96.7 (95% CI 94-98.4). For the classification of samples from previously infected individuals, sensitivity and specificity were 83.4% (95% CI 76.7-88.9) and 100% (95% CI 98.8-100). Conclusion: This study establishes the sensitivity and specificity for a high-throughput assay ideal for SARS-CoV-2 seroprevalence studies. Future research should focus on applying this assay in health care settings to guide practice and policy to mitigate the pandemic.